Failed Experiment #52, Makeup Edition

Since I regularly mix a bit of foundation with my moisturizer, smear it on my face, and call it makeup, I was intrigued when I saw Neutrogena Healthy Skin Enhancer Tinted Moisturizer on drugstore.com. I was shopping during the 20%-off-your-entire-order sale, so I bought one. Unfortunately, "Light to Neutral" turned out to be about 40 shades darker than my actual skin tone, and I didn't realize that drugstore.com guaranteed the color of makeup, so I threw out the packing sleep (<-Freudian sleep there, I guess) slip I'd need to return it.

Anyway, undeterred, I went to CVS last night to see if there was a lighter color of the stuff. There was; in fact, there were two shades that were lighter than the one I'd ordered. I went with the lightest, Ivory to Fair. Alas, still too dark by several shades:

brown face, white neck

Does anyone want a bottle of tinted moisturizer in Ivory to Light (10) or Light to Neutral (30), each used only once? I'd rather mail them to a reader than have a Freecycle stranger come all the way to my house for a bottle of makeup.

Posted by Lori in failed experiments and me, me, me at 10:10 AM on December 14, 2006

Comments (2)

Can't you just use your online order confirmation to do the return? I do that with other retailers, and there's no problem.

If you really can't, I'd give the Ivory to Light a try.

Josie [TypeKey Profile Page]:

Man...you're white!

Comments

Can't you just use your online order confirmation to do the return? I do that with other retailers, and there's no problem.

If you really can't, I'd give the Ivory to Light a try.

Posted by: ratphooey [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 14, 2006 10:35 AM

Man...you're white!

Posted by: Josie [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 18, 2006 12:04 PM

Comments are now closed.